Skip to content

Creativity ​

One slider on Song Brief and Cover Brief: 0 steady ... 50 the reference ... 100 experimental (the default) ... 200 adventurous. It makes a song simpler and more predictable, or bolder and more surprising - in the writing and, with YuE2, in how freely the score is planned and performed.

Since 1.5.0 the slider goes to 200, and 100 is the default. Up to 100 every value means exactly what it meant before: 50 is how Plenio worked before the slider existed, 100 the experimental setting of 1.4. 101-200 goes further. A workflow saved with an earlier version keeps its value (a 1.4 workflow usually 50 - set 100 for the new default); a workflow saved before the slider existed, and an API request without the field, get the default 100.

What it changes ​

0-19 steady20-39 restrained40-60 balanced61-80 varied81-150 experimental151-200 adventurous
Lyricsplain everyday words, short regular lines, simple rhymes; the chorus repeats word for wordfamiliar images, regular lines, a repeated chorusas before the sliderfresh, concrete images; line lengths and rhythm differ between sections; the hook stays, its last repeat may change a few wordsan unexpected angle and imagery, inventive rhymes and rhythms; may add one contrasting section (a bridge, or a break before the last chorus)a surprising perspective - an object that speaks, a letter, a dialogue, a story told from its end - with vivid unusual images; the chorus hook stays simple enough to sing along; may add a contrasting section
Style (YuE2)the genre's usual instruments, one steady groove, a simple productionthe genre's usual soundas before the sliderthe same short line, more specific: named instruments and how they are played, a production colour, a word or two for contrast and movementas varied, plus one unexpected but fitting colour - an unusual instrument, a touch of a neighbouring genre, an uncommon rhythm feelas varied, plus two such colours
Caption (MiniMax)one steady groove, the same instruments throughouta conventional arrangementas before the sliderthe Arrangement part tells an arc of contrasts: an intimate start, a build, a full high point, a contrasting bridge or a breakdown, instruments answering the voiceas varied, plus one surprising turn: a key lift, a change of rhythm feel or an unusual soloas varied, plus two surprising turns - the song still flows as one

The sampling moves smoothly with the slider, in straight lines between the values below:

050100200
Writer's temperature (first draft)0.60.81.01.1
Creative mode's plan (temperature)0.550.70.91.0
YuE2 plan: temperature / top-p / top-k0.55 / 0.85 / 200.7 / 0.9 / 300.92 / 0.95 / 501.0 / 0.96 / 64
YuE2 take: temperature / top-p / top-k0.9 / 0.92 / 601.0 / 0.95 / 1001.1 / 0.97 / 1501.15 / 0.98 / 200

The plan is the score (notes, chords, rhythms), the take the performance (voice, instruments, sound). The values at 50 are YuE2's own defaults. Above 100 the slider stays moderate on purpose: there is no official guidance for YuE2's sampling, and users report that a plan temperature above 1.0 and a take temperature above 1.15 lose the song's thread - so 200 stops at those edges and only widens top-p and top-k a little. The repetition penalties are never changed - music lives from repetition - nor is MiniMax Music 3's own sampling.

Why the YuE2 style gets more specific, not longer ​

YuE2 reads its style as a short list of descriptors, and longer style prose was sung by it in tests. So a more varied style stays one line of about 40 words and swaps generic words for exact ones:

  • reference: English, warm piano pop, expressive female voice, acoustic piano, rounded bass and light drums, lyrical memorable melody, unhurried phrasing, 88 BPM
  • varied: English, indie folk-pop, breathy female alto, fingerpicked nylon guitar, muted trumpet, pulsing upright bass, brushed drums, sparse-to-full contrast, dynamic build-ups, instrumental fills between phrases, layered backing vocals, 92 BPM

Good to know ​

  • More surprises, more misses. Above 100, listen to a few takes: the take seed 🎲 renders a new one every run, and in a cover YuE2 Takes renders several at once.
  • Song sections with a plan - quiet verses and a big final chorus, instruments answering the voice, a breakdown, a key change - are the creative modes (arrangement on the brief). The slider does not switch them on; with one on, it sets how freely the writer plans.
  • When a finished score reaches YuE2 - a creative mode's arrangement, a score you edited, the DAW template - YuE2 does not plan any more, so only the take's sampling follows the slider.
  • A workflow saved before the slider: when it opens, Plenio gives it the current blocks - Write Song, Arrange and the YuE2 blocks - and links the YuE2 blocks' creativity to the brief, so the slider reaches the sampling as in the current template; a message names the blocks. Save the workflow to keep it. A block whose sampling you changed inside it stays as it was (the message says so); its numbers stay fixed.
  • In the player a song whose workflow had its sampling fixed while the brief asked for another creativity says so beside the numbers: fixed in the workflow, not from the creativity.
  • Other ways to more variety: another draft seed, thinking on Write Song with a model that reasons, a larger writer model, a key or meter in the brief (D dorian, 6/8).
  • Tags: {creativity} puts the value into a tag or a file name (Export Release).
  • In the Plenio Player a song's Details show its creativity and the sampling it gave, and the filters have a Creativity row; the search takes creativity:>100 or creativity:adventurous. Songs made before the slider count as 50: they were made as 50 makes them now.

The research and the decisions behind the values: docs/design/creativity.md.